Housing Security Versus Children’s Inheritance

Many families face the same estate planning challenge: how do you protect a surviving partner while leaving an inheritance for children?

A right to live in the family home to the spouse can seem like a good solution. However, Pettit v Davis [2026] NSWSC 1363 shows why that arrangement might not be seen as adequate provision. The Court must consider estate expenses, changing housing needs and competing family claims.

Background: 29 years of marriage

Christopher and Danuta Pettit began their relationship in 1991 and married in 1995. Both had children from previous marriages.

Danuta used inherited money to purchase their Maitland home for $125,000 in 2003. It was registered solely in her name.

Christopher worked as a paramedic and supported the couple financially for much of their relationship. They later borrowed $80,000 against the property, partly to build a garage. He used money from his inheritance and superannuation to discharge the mortgage and fund kitchen and bathroom renovations. The Court recognised approximately $120,000 in contributions to improvements.

Christopher also helped manage Danuta’s diabetes and provided personal care after her advanced lung cancer diagnosis. She died in November 2024.

Why did the Will create difficulties?

Danuta’s 2005 Will allowed Christopher to live in the home rent-free, subject to conditions. He had to pay outgoings and maintain it. His right could end if he remarried, entered a de facto relationship or stopped living there permanently. The property was then to be sold, with the proceeds passing to Danuta’s two children.

However, the home was effectively the estate’s only asset. Approximately $7,764 in estate liabilities could not be paid from other funds. The parties agreed that selling it to meet those liabilities would extinguish Christopher’s right of residence.

The home’s estimated value was $785,000. After estimated sale expenses, estate liabilities and both parties’ legal costs, approximately $642,395 would remain, before any executor’s commission.

Christopher, then 70, was retired and relied on the Age Pension. He had approximately $200 in the bank, credit card debts and several health conditions.

He sought approximately $611,646 outright for housing, debts and contingencies. The executor proposed $350,000. Danuta’s children also had financial and health difficulties, which the Court needed to consider.

What did the Court decide?

The Court found that Christopher had not received adequate provision. His housing right would disappear on sale and offered no flexibility if he later needed alternative accommodation.

His long marriage, financial contributions, care for Danuta and limited ability to improve his finances strengthened his claim. However, awarding almost everything outright would inadequately recognise the children’s competing claims.

The Court outlined a different arrangement:

  • $120,000 outright to Christopher, reflecting his contributions to improvements.
  • The remaining net sale proceeds as a loan to help him purchase accommodation in his own name.
  • A charge over that accommodation, or replacement accommodation, securing repayment for the children. The loan would increase with the Consumer Price Index and, if not repayable earlier, be repaid from Christopher’s estate on his death.

This aimed to provide housing and independence while preserving an eventual inheritance for the children. The parties were directed to prepare orders implementing the reasons.

What does this mean for you?

For surviving partners: Receiving something under a Will does not necessarily mean your needs are adequately met. A conditional housing right may be insufficient where you cannot afford expenses or need to move.

For adult children: A surviving spouse does not automatically receive the whole estate. Your circumstances and the deceased’s wishes can remain relevant.

For anyone preparing a Will: Consider how estate bills will be paid, who pays property expenses and what happens if your partner needs to downsize or enter aged care. Review arrangements as circumstances change.

Can you seek further provision?

An eligible person may bring a family provision claim. NSW applications generally must be filed within 12 months of death, subject to exceptions. Keep records of contributions, care, finances and housing needs.

The Law Office of Conrad Curry advises on estate planning and family provision claims across Newcastle, the Central Coast and NSW. Contact our team to discuss your circumstances.

DISCLAIMER

This article reflects the current law at the time of publication. Please note that cases may have been the subject to appeal or subsequent judicial consideration since the date of posting. The decisions referred to are summarised for general understanding only. It is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance in relation to your situation, please consult with a qualified legal professional.

Recent Articles

Conrad Curry

Who Inherits a Forfeited Share?

Wills and Estates
18 November 2026
Charlotte Walters

Car Accident Claims: Don’t Delay

Motor Vehicle Claims
10 November 2026
The Law Office of Conrad Curry

Tom Hunter-Leahy Retains Specialist Status for 4th Year

Personal Injury, Staff Stories
10 November 2026