A son who murdered his mother could not inherit under her will. But could the Court give his share to his daughter instead?
That was the question in Toohey v Mapp [2026] NSWSC 1417. The NSW Supreme Court’s decision explains how the forfeiture rule can affect an estate and why a disqualified beneficiary cannot simply choose someone else to receive their inheritance.
Background to the estate dispute
Colleen Janette Wilson made her will on 29 November 2016. After some smaller gifts, her principal beneficiaries were her sons, David Andrew Mapp and Steven James Mapp.
David murdered his mother on or about 28 July 2022. He was convicted by a jury and sentenced to 21 years’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 15 years.
Steven survived his mother but subsequently died. His estate therefore had an interest in how Mrs Wilson’s estate would be distributed.
Jennifer Margaret Toohey, the executor of Mrs Wilson’s estate, brought proceedings concerning the forfeiture rule. David was the first defendant, while Jenny Lee Colleen Mapp, the administrator of Steven’s estate, was the second defendant.
Justice Kunc heard and determined the matter on 29 October 2026.
Why did the Court consider the murder conviction?
The forfeiture rule prevents a person from benefiting from their own unlawful killing of another person. However, the Court still needed to be satisfied on the civil standard of proof that David had unlawfully killed his mother.
Justice Kunc relied on three matters:
- The criminal conviction: A Supreme Court certificate confirming David’s conviction was tendered. The judge noted that this was not necessarily sufficient by itself.
- Admissions in the estate proceedings: David received a formal notice asking him to admit facts. He did not dispute it, meaning those facts were treated as admitted.
- David’s own position: He accepted that he had murdered his mother and understood that he was ineligible to inherit.
David appeared by audiovisual link from prison. He did not oppose the proceedings and told the Court he did not wish to seek further legal advice.
The Court found that he had murdered Mrs Wilson and was prevented from receiving any asset under her will.
Why could his daughter not receive his share?
David had written to the judge and also addressed the Court, asking that his inheritance go to his daughter.
Justice Kunc acknowledged the request as understandable from a father wishing to benefit his child. However, that did not give the Court power to change the outcome.
The executor’s barrister submitted that the Court could not redirect the forfeited gift as David requested. The judge agreed.
There was no dispute that, under Mrs Wilson’s will as affected by the forfeiture rule, Steven’s estate received the share otherwise intended for David. The Court declared that the administrator of Steven’s estate was entitled to the whole residuary estate: what remained after debts, expenses and other gifts.
The executor’s costs, assessed on the indemnity basis, and the second defendant’s costs were payable from Mrs Wilson’s estate. David had to meet any costs he incurred himself.
What does this mean for NSW estate disputes?
- A lost inheritance cannot simply be redirected. David’s request did not give his daughter an entitlement. The will and the applicable law determined who received his share.
- Replacement beneficiary clauses matter. When preparing a will, consider what should happen if an intended beneficiary cannot inherit. Clear drafting can help address unexpected circumstances.
- A beneficiary’s later death can involve another estate. Steven survived his mother, so his subsequent death did not prevent his estate receiving the benefit.
- Executors should seek advice before distributing disputed assets. This case shows why court declarations may be needed to establish who is entitled to inherit.
How we can help
The Law Office of Conrad Curry advises executors and families on contested probate, estate administration and estate disputes throughout NSW. Contact our Newcastle or Central Coast team to discuss your circumstances.
Source: Toohey v Mapp [2026] NSWSC 1417, judgment delivered 29 October 2026.
DISCLAIMER
This article reflects the current law at the time of publication. Please note that cases may have been the subject to appeal or subsequent judicial consideration since the date of posting. The decisions referred to are summarised for general understanding only. It is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For specific legal guidance in relation to your situation, please consult with a qualified legal professional.